Lil' Sugar Cookies: Simple, easy-to-make, soft, and chewy basic sugar cookies.

Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

Lil' Sugar Cookies

"Lil' Sugar" is the name that one of the nurses called my baby Margo when she was giving her the first bath in the delivery room at the hospital after she was born in the Spring.

It is now about one year and 20 days since that rainy, Spring evening she was born, my second Mother's Day with her has passed and I am ever, eternally grateful to have her in my life.

Margo, my husband, Eric and I, all have this special bond together and when I think about how much meaning my family brings to life, my heart bursts with joy.

Lil' Sugar Cookies are not your typical dry, hard, crumbly sugar cookies and they are not like shortbread either, Ewww gross, we don’t like that kind of sugar cookies, yucky.

Fear not, sugar cookie-phobes, these cookies are not those greasy, grainy, gritty texture between your molars kind of sugar cookies.

Did someone put sand in those cookies? Because we don’t like those, either, ick.

These cookies are chewy and soft in the center with crisp outer edges which makes for a satisfying bite each time. 

Yummy, yum, yum…(can you tell I am eating one?)

The butter flavor comes through very well while being pleasantly sweet and expects more of a light and airy experience. 

They remind me of a really fresh Italian cookie from Modern Pastry in Boston, MA (a favorite haunt when visiting family). 

Like most things I bake, they make a nice buddy to coffee or might I suggest a smoky, black tea to go with your Lil’ Sugar Cookies.

Ingredients

• ½ cup butter, (1 stick) softened to room temperature
• 1-½ cups sugar
• 2 eggs
• 1 teaspoon cream of tartar
• 1 teaspoon baking soda
• 1 teaspoon vanilla
• ¼ teaspoon kosher salt
• 2-¾ cups flour

Kitchen Tools

• measuring spoons and cups
• 2-cup measure
• mixing bowls
• baking spatula
• cookie scoop
• silicone baking mat(s) or parchment paper
• rimmed baking sheet(s)
• wire cooling rack

Web Story

Recipe Tips

I use an OXO Good Grips Medium Cookie Dough Scoop for getting perfectly rounded scoops of dough and it results in nicely shaped cookies when they are done baking.

I have tried two other cookie dough scoops (both of which broke) and this one is sturdy, well made, and comfortable to use.

Using a cookie dough scoop cuts down on mess, reduces "cookie spread" and gives you better-looking cookies.

The OXO scoop makes rounded shapes that resemble scooped ice cream.

I usually do 12 scoops of dough per baking sheet, and there will be some extra, so I just bake in shifts.

Recipe Attribution

This recipe is adapted from "Old Fashioned Sugar Cookies" on p. 248 of the Better Homes and Gardens New Cook Book.

Recipe Notes, Alternatives + Thoughts

• Do not refrigerate the cookie dough as it says in the original recipe, I had tried this and it makes it much more difficult to scoop the dough with the scoop.
• Keep an eye on the time when baking these, I have an electric stove and every stove can differ slightly when it comes to baking times.
• It is important that the butter be creamed properly in the beginning; this helps with getting that light and airy texture that makes these cookies so delicious.
• You can try a different type of extract other than vanilla
• You can try sprinkling rainbow or chocolate sprinkles on top for a festive look.

Best Wishes and Happy Baking!

Latest Recipes and Posts

• Instant Pot Black Eyed Peas
• Sand Tart Cookie Recipe
• Slow Cooker Crock-Pot Butter Corn
• Homemade Coffee Creamer
• Maple Cinnamon Butter